Darwin’s Evolutionary Theory as Reflected in the Russian Conservative and Liberal Press of the Second Half of the 19th Century

Download paper
Olga S. Kruglikova

PhD in Philology, Associate Professor at the Chair of Journalism History, St. Petersburg State University, St. Petersburg, Russia

e-mail: oskruglikova@spbu.ru

Section: History of Journalism

The article analyses the polemic about Darwinism in the Russian press of the second half of the 19th century. This controversy made the problems of natural science part of the worldview and political debate between liberals and conservatives. In the 1880s, two journals, the liberal Russkaya Mysl and the conservative Russkiy Vestnik, discussed N. Ya. Danilevsky’s book “Darwinism: the Critical Analysis”. For the authors of the former publication (K. A. Timiryazev, N. G. Chernyshevsky), the affirmation of the natural origin of the Earth and the human being was the basis for the struggle against clericalism. But some of them, the followers of socialist views, denied the struggle for existence as a factor in evolution, believing that this factor was not competition but cooperation. In Russkiy Vestnik, the conservatives (N. N. Strakhov) criticized Darwinism, defending the idea of creationism and development of nature in accordance with the divine plan of the Creator. The analysis of this polemic, as compared with up-to-date realities, makes it possible to assert that the involvement of scientific popularization in political discourse is one of the characteristic features of the Russian press throughout its existence.

Keywords: N. Ya. Danilevsky, N. N. Strakhov, K. A. Timiryazev, N. G. Chernyshevsky, Darwinism, Russkiy Vestnik, Russkaya Mysl
DOI: 10.30547/vestnik.joum.5.2018.101118

References:

Danilevskiy N. Ya. (1885) Darvinizm. Kriticheskoe issledovanie [Darvinism. A Critical Analysis]. Peterburg: Izdanie M. E. Komarova. (In Russian)

Danilevskiy N. Ya. (2008) Rossiya i Evropa. Vzglyad na kul’turnye i politicheskie otnosheniya slavyanskogo mira k romano-germanskomu [Russia and Europe. A Glance at the Cultural and Political Attitudes of the Slavic World to the Romano-Germanic One]. Moscow: Institut russkoy tsivilizatsii. (In Russian)

«Darvinizm» N. Ya. Danilevskogo v otsenke russkikh filosofov, istorikov i teoretikov biologii [“Darvinism” by N. Danilevsky in the Assessment of Russian Philosophers, Historians and Biology Theorists] (2016) Lethaea rossica 12: 47–62. (In Russian)

Efremov A. V. (2016) Kliment Timiryazev kak kritik Danilevskogo [Kliment Timiryazev as a Critic of Danilevsky]. In Tvorcheskoe nasledie Nikolaya Yakovlevicha Danilevskogo i ego znachenie dlya nauchnoy mysli Rossii i Kryma: materialy Mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii (g. Simferopol’, 21–23 May 2015 g.) [Creative Legacy of Nikolai Danilevsky and Its Significance for Scientific Thought in Russia and Crimea: proceedings of the International Research-to-Practice Conference (Simferopol, May 21–23, 2015]. Kursk: Kurskaya gosudarstvennaya sel’skokhozyaystvennaya akademiya Publ. Pp. 201–206. (In Russian)

Kantor V. K. (2005) Khristianskiy pafos Nikolaya Chernyshevskogo: srublennoe «drevo zhizni» rossiyskoy sud’by [The Christian Pathos of Nikolai Crenyshevsky: the Cut Down “Tree of Life” of Russian Fate]. In Ocherki russkoy kul’tury XIX v. T. 5. Khudozhestvennaya literatura. Russkiy yazyk [Essays on 19th Century Russian Culture. Vol. 5. Literary Fiction. Russian Language]. Moscow: Mosk. Univ. Publ. Pp. 186–234. (In Russian)

Khudozhestvennaya literatura. Russkiy yazyk [Essays on 19th Century Russian Culture. Vol. 5. Literary Fiction. Russian Language]. Moscow: Mosk. Univ. Publ. Pp. 186–234. (In Russian)

Lisachenko D. A. (2018) Nauchno-populyarnoe mediaprostranstvo: vzglyad snizu [Popular Science Media Scene: Bottom View]. In Vek informatsii. Media v sovremennom mire. Peterburgskie chteniya: mater. 57-go mezhdunar. foruma (19–20 aprelya 2018 g.) № 2. T. 1 [Information Age. Media in the Modern World. St. Petersburg Readings: proceedings of the 57th International Forum (April 19–20, 2018). № 2. Vol. 1]. St. Petersburg: Vyssh. shk. zhurn. i mas. kommunikatsiy Publ. Pp. 109–110. (In Russian)

Lishevskiy V. P. (1987) Uchenye - populyarizatory nauki [Scientists as Science Popularizers]. Moscow: Znanie Publ. (In Russian). Availabe at: http://n-t.ru/ri/ls/up04.html

Nazarov V. I. (2005) Evolyutsiya ne po Darvinu: smena evolyutsionnoy modeli [Evolution Alternative to Darwin: a Change of the Evolutionary Model]. Moscow: KomKniga Publ. (In Russian)

Pozdnyakov A. A. (2016) Teoretiko-biologicheskie predstavleniya N. Ya. Danilevskogo [Theoretical and Biological Views of N. Danilevsky]. Lethaea rossica 12: 33–46. (In Russian)

Sorokin Yu. (1955) D. I. Pisarev [D. Pisarev]. In Sochineniya v chetyrekh tomakh. Tom 1. Stat’i i retsenzii 1859–1862 [Writings in Four Volumes. Vol. 1. Articles and Reviews of 1859–1862]. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo khudozhestvennoy literatury. (In Russian). Available at:http://www.classic-book.ru/lib/sb/book/100 

Trapezov O. V. (2009) Darvinizm i uroki rossiyskoy prakticheskoy selektsii [Darwinism and the Lessons of Russian Practical Selection]. Vestnik VOGiS 13 (2): 249–297. (In Russian)